Melbourne Storm
go_manly
April 22, 2010 at 01:14 PM posted in General DiscussionWow! Melbourne stripped of the 2007 and 2009 premierships. Why won't they award Manly the 2007 premiership?
bababardwan
April 23, 2010 at 12:12 PM
hehe,I just spotted that narrow escape. Ah yes, I get the first part of crouching tiger analogy now.
go_manly
April 23, 2010 at 12:07 PM
Yes, but not that season thank god. He was with the Tigers that year, hence the 'crouching Tiger' analogy. Hopoate was nurtured by players with more class while at Manly.
(and I'll thank you not to bring up Ian Roberts)
bababardwan
April 23, 2010 at 12:04 PM
He played for Manly didn't he mate?
If you can confirm this, what are we to make of someone who calls themself "go_manly" and what exactly is the "go" encouraging ? ;)
go_manly
April 23, 2010 at 11:59 AM
I think most League players manage to avoid smelling bums. Except perhaps John Hopoate, who wanted to take the smell home with him, viz. the infamous "Crouching Tiger Hidden Finger" incident.
waiguoren
April 23, 2010 at 11:46 AM
哈哈哈哈。。。
Keen observations, I must admit, but I don't see how a game where you smell each others bums is in any way superior...
How many lessons does ChinesePod have on 'Rugby'?
@bababardwan
So I take it that 科灵伍德 is a transliteration of Collingwood?
谢谢
go_manly
April 23, 2010 at 11:28 AM
Real footy? You have a bunch of guys with shorts halfway up their ass, fumbling after a ball, for the most part unsuccessfully, like inmates fighting over a cake of soap in a prison shower. And when someone actually catches the ball, the game stops, and to celebrate such a rare event, the miracle-worker is awarded a free shot at goal.
bababardwan
April 23, 2010 at 11:19 AM
谈到讨论这里这样的而保持它有关中文,有人【特别是中国人】可能喜欢知道澳大利亚足球规则也叫“空中的乒乓“【因为听说多中国人喜欢乒乓球】
waiguoren
April 23, 2010 at 11:05 AM
Can any of those blokes play real footy (i.e. AFL)? Maybe they should swap codes since Melbourne have forfeited playing for points for the remainder of the season.
The same thing happened in the AFL a few years ago with Carlton (who won a premiership in 1995, when alleged salary cap breaches took place). They were fined and stripped of draft picks for a few years, and subsequently languished on the bottom of the ladder (much to my delight) for the next few years. Fair enough I thought.
Don't know much about NRL, but stripping the Storm of points for the rest of the season is a bit much isn't it? Let alone taking 'their' premierships away.
Kind of feel bad having this discussion on ChinesePod, so I will have to attempt some Chinese: 加油 Collingwood!
bodawei
April 23, 2010 at 08:14 AM
With Greg Florimo and Gary Larsen strapping on the boots again. :)
You might be right - I find it hard to imagine Melbourne failing. At least I like to watch them play.
你住在北悉尼,真的吗?欢迎。 我一般住在北悉尼城市中心。
go_manly
April 23, 2010 at 08:05 AM
My prediction for the ultimate outcome of this fiasco: Melbourne unable to survive, and replaced by the Central Coast Bears. As I now live in the heart of North Sydney territory, perhaps you will see a name-change from me in the future.
(BTW, how could all the players be innocent? Did none of them notice that, their bank-balance was larger than it should have been? And have they declared this extra payment for tax purposes?)
bodawei
April 23, 2010 at 07:48 AM
Good point Go_manly. It's a multi-variate problem. Melbourne is continuing to cheat because you can't just go and sack the players (assuming they are innocent.) That could continue to the point that all of those contracts expire. Although I am not a die-hard fan any more I still love the game.
go_manly
April 22, 2010 at 09:55 PM
Well, this year Melbourne have been stripped of all their points, not a certain percentage. As a result, another team will be awarded the premiership even if Melbourne prove to be the best team in the comp by winning the most games. Will that team deserve the premiership?
bodawei
April 22, 2010 at 03:05 PMIt's a good question, but I think there is a difference between one side cheating and the other side being awarded victory. Say, for example, Melbourne were able to keep two players by virtue of their cheating and this gave them say a '10%' advantage (this is just a thought experiment). What if then Melbourne beat Manly by 60-0. Does Manly deserve the Premiership? I'm not being high and mighty; my team Canberra cheated the cap a few years ago. They are getting along now with possibly the cheapest players in the competition.